Thu, Jan 1, 2026

Propagation anomalies - 2026-01-01

Detection of blocks that propagated slower than expected, attempting to find correlations with blob count.

Show code
display_sql("block_production_timeline", target_date)
View query
WITH
-- Base slots using proposer duty as the source of truth
slots AS (
    SELECT DISTINCT
        slot,
        slot_start_date_time,
        proposer_validator_index
    FROM canonical_beacon_proposer_duty
    WHERE meta_network_name = 'mainnet'
      AND slot_start_date_time >= '2026-01-01' AND slot_start_date_time < '2026-01-01'::date + INTERVAL 1 DAY
),

-- Proposer entity mapping
proposer_entity AS (
    SELECT
        index,
        entity
    FROM ethseer_validator_entity
    WHERE meta_network_name = 'mainnet'
),

-- Blob count per slot
blob_count AS (
    SELECT
        slot,
        uniq(blob_index) AS blob_count
    FROM canonical_beacon_blob_sidecar
    WHERE meta_network_name = 'mainnet'
      AND slot_start_date_time >= '2026-01-01' AND slot_start_date_time < '2026-01-01'::date + INTERVAL 1 DAY
    GROUP BY slot
),

-- Canonical block hash (to verify MEV payload was actually used)
canonical_block AS (
    SELECT DISTINCT
        slot,
        execution_payload_block_hash
    FROM canonical_beacon_block
    WHERE meta_network_name = 'mainnet'
      AND slot_start_date_time >= '2026-01-01' AND slot_start_date_time < '2026-01-01'::date + INTERVAL 1 DAY
),

-- MEV bid timing using timestamp_ms
mev_bids AS (
    SELECT
        slot,
        slot_start_date_time,
        min(timestamp_ms) AS first_bid_timestamp_ms,
        max(timestamp_ms) AS last_bid_timestamp_ms
    FROM mev_relay_bid_trace
    WHERE meta_network_name = 'mainnet'
      AND slot_start_date_time >= '2026-01-01' AND slot_start_date_time < '2026-01-01'::date + INTERVAL 1 DAY
    GROUP BY slot, slot_start_date_time
),

-- MEV payload delivery - join canonical block with delivered payloads
-- Note: Use is_mev flag because ClickHouse LEFT JOIN returns 0 (not NULL) for non-matching rows
-- Get value from proposer_payload_delivered (not bid_trace, which may not have the winning block)
mev_payload AS (
    SELECT
        cb.slot,
        cb.execution_payload_block_hash AS winning_block_hash,
        1 AS is_mev,
        max(pd.value) AS winning_bid_value,
        groupArray(DISTINCT pd.relay_name) AS relay_names,
        any(pd.builder_pubkey) AS winning_builder
    FROM canonical_block cb
    GLOBAL INNER JOIN mev_relay_proposer_payload_delivered pd
        ON cb.slot = pd.slot AND cb.execution_payload_block_hash = pd.block_hash
    WHERE pd.meta_network_name = 'mainnet'
      AND slot_start_date_time >= '2026-01-01' AND slot_start_date_time < '2026-01-01'::date + INTERVAL 1 DAY
    GROUP BY cb.slot, cb.execution_payload_block_hash
),

-- Winning bid timing from bid_trace (may not exist for all MEV blocks)
winning_bid AS (
    SELECT
        bt.slot,
        bt.slot_start_date_time,
        argMin(bt.timestamp_ms, bt.event_date_time) AS winning_bid_timestamp_ms
    FROM mev_relay_bid_trace bt
    GLOBAL INNER JOIN mev_payload mp ON bt.slot = mp.slot AND bt.block_hash = mp.winning_block_hash
    WHERE bt.meta_network_name = 'mainnet'
      AND slot_start_date_time >= '2026-01-01' AND slot_start_date_time < '2026-01-01'::date + INTERVAL 1 DAY
    GROUP BY bt.slot, bt.slot_start_date_time
),

-- Block gossip timing with spread
block_gossip AS (
    SELECT
        slot,
        min(event_date_time) AS block_first_seen,
        max(event_date_time) AS block_last_seen
    FROM libp2p_gossipsub_beacon_block
    WHERE meta_network_name = 'mainnet'
      AND slot_start_date_time >= '2026-01-01' AND slot_start_date_time < '2026-01-01'::date + INTERVAL 1 DAY
    GROUP BY slot
),

-- Column arrival timing: first arrival per column, then min/max of those
column_gossip AS (
    SELECT
        slot,
        min(first_seen) AS first_column_first_seen,
        max(first_seen) AS last_column_first_seen
    FROM (
        SELECT
            slot,
            column_index,
            min(event_date_time) AS first_seen
        FROM libp2p_gossipsub_data_column_sidecar
        WHERE meta_network_name = 'mainnet'
          AND slot_start_date_time >= '2026-01-01' AND slot_start_date_time < '2026-01-01'::date + INTERVAL 1 DAY
          AND event_date_time > '1970-01-01 00:00:01'
        GROUP BY slot, column_index
    )
    GROUP BY slot
)

SELECT
    s.slot AS slot,
    s.slot_start_date_time AS slot_start_date_time,
    pe.entity AS proposer_entity,

    -- Blob count
    coalesce(bc.blob_count, 0) AS blob_count,

    -- MEV bid timing (absolute and relative to slot start)
    fromUnixTimestamp64Milli(mb.first_bid_timestamp_ms) AS first_bid_at,
    mb.first_bid_timestamp_ms - toInt64(toUnixTimestamp(mb.slot_start_date_time)) * 1000 AS first_bid_ms,
    fromUnixTimestamp64Milli(mb.last_bid_timestamp_ms) AS last_bid_at,
    mb.last_bid_timestamp_ms - toInt64(toUnixTimestamp(mb.slot_start_date_time)) * 1000 AS last_bid_ms,

    -- Winning bid timing (from bid_trace, may be NULL if block hash not in bid_trace)
    if(wb.slot != 0, fromUnixTimestamp64Milli(wb.winning_bid_timestamp_ms), NULL) AS winning_bid_at,
    if(wb.slot != 0, wb.winning_bid_timestamp_ms - toInt64(toUnixTimestamp(s.slot_start_date_time)) * 1000, NULL) AS winning_bid_ms,

    -- MEV payload info (from proposer_payload_delivered, always present for MEV blocks)
    if(mp.is_mev = 1, mp.winning_bid_value, NULL) AS winning_bid_value,
    if(mp.is_mev = 1, mp.relay_names, []) AS winning_relays,
    if(mp.is_mev = 1, mp.winning_builder, NULL) AS winning_builder,

    -- Block gossip timing with spread
    bg.block_first_seen,
    dateDiff('millisecond', s.slot_start_date_time, bg.block_first_seen) AS block_first_seen_ms,
    bg.block_last_seen,
    dateDiff('millisecond', s.slot_start_date_time, bg.block_last_seen) AS block_last_seen_ms,
    dateDiff('millisecond', bg.block_first_seen, bg.block_last_seen) AS block_spread_ms,

    -- Column arrival timing (NULL when no blobs)
    if(coalesce(bc.blob_count, 0) = 0, NULL, cg.first_column_first_seen) AS first_column_first_seen,
    if(coalesce(bc.blob_count, 0) = 0, NULL, dateDiff('millisecond', s.slot_start_date_time, cg.first_column_first_seen)) AS first_column_first_seen_ms,
    if(coalesce(bc.blob_count, 0) = 0, NULL, cg.last_column_first_seen) AS last_column_first_seen,
    if(coalesce(bc.blob_count, 0) = 0, NULL, dateDiff('millisecond', s.slot_start_date_time, cg.last_column_first_seen)) AS last_column_first_seen_ms,
    if(coalesce(bc.blob_count, 0) = 0, NULL, dateDiff('millisecond', cg.first_column_first_seen, cg.last_column_first_seen)) AS column_spread_ms

FROM slots s
GLOBAL LEFT JOIN proposer_entity pe ON s.proposer_validator_index = pe.index
GLOBAL LEFT JOIN blob_count bc ON s.slot = bc.slot
GLOBAL LEFT JOIN mev_bids mb ON s.slot = mb.slot
GLOBAL LEFT JOIN mev_payload mp ON s.slot = mp.slot
GLOBAL LEFT JOIN winning_bid wb ON s.slot = wb.slot
GLOBAL LEFT JOIN block_gossip bg ON s.slot = bg.slot
GLOBAL LEFT JOIN column_gossip cg ON s.slot = cg.slot

ORDER BY s.slot DESC
Show code
df = load_parquet("block_production_timeline", target_date)

# Filter to valid blocks (exclude missed slots)
df = df[df["block_first_seen_ms"].notna()]
df = df[(df["block_first_seen_ms"] >= 0) & (df["block_first_seen_ms"] < 60000)]

# Flag MEV vs local blocks
df["has_mev"] = df["winning_bid_value"].notna()
df["block_type"] = df["has_mev"].map({True: "MEV", False: "Local"})

# Get max blob count for charts
max_blobs = df["blob_count"].max()

print(f"Total valid blocks: {len(df):,}")
print(f"MEV blocks: {df['has_mev'].sum():,} ({df['has_mev'].mean()*100:.1f}%)")
print(f"Local blocks: {(~df['has_mev']).sum():,} ({(~df['has_mev']).mean()*100:.1f}%)")
Total valid blocks: 7,179
MEV blocks: 6,676 (93.0%)
Local blocks: 503 (7.0%)

Anomaly detection method

The method:

  1. Fit linear regression: block_first_seen_ms ~ blob_count
  2. Calculate residuals (actual - expected)
  3. Flag blocks with residuals > 2σ as anomalies

Points above the ±2σ band propagated slower than expected given their blob count.

Show code
# Conditional outliers: blocks slow relative to their blob count
df_anomaly = df.copy()

# Fit regression: block_first_seen_ms ~ blob_count
slope, intercept, r_value, p_value, std_err = stats.linregress(
    df_anomaly["blob_count"].astype(float), df_anomaly["block_first_seen_ms"]
)

# Calculate expected value and residual
df_anomaly["expected_ms"] = intercept + slope * df_anomaly["blob_count"].astype(float)
df_anomaly["residual_ms"] = df_anomaly["block_first_seen_ms"] - df_anomaly["expected_ms"]

# Calculate residual standard deviation
residual_std = df_anomaly["residual_ms"].std()

# Flag anomalies: residual > 2σ (unexpectedly slow)
df_anomaly["is_anomaly"] = df_anomaly["residual_ms"] > 2 * residual_std

n_anomalies = df_anomaly["is_anomaly"].sum()
pct_anomalies = n_anomalies / len(df_anomaly) * 100

# Prepare outliers dataframe
df_outliers = df_anomaly[df_anomaly["is_anomaly"]].copy()
df_outliers["relay"] = df_outliers["winning_relays"].apply(lambda x: x[0] if len(x) > 0 else "Local")
df_outliers["proposer"] = df_outliers["proposer_entity"].fillna("Unknown")
df_outliers["builder"] = df_outliers["winning_builder"].apply(
    lambda x: f"{x[:10]}..." if pd.notna(x) and x else "Local"
)

print(f"Regression: block_ms = {intercept:.1f} + {slope:.2f} × blob_count (R² = {r_value**2:.3f})")
print(f"Residual σ = {residual_std:.1f}ms")
print(f"Anomalies (>2σ slow): {n_anomalies:,} ({pct_anomalies:.1f}%)")
Regression: block_ms = 1747.7 + 19.54 × blob_count (R² = 0.013)
Residual σ = 609.7ms
Anomalies (>2σ slow): 296 (4.1%)
Show code
# Create scatter plot with regression band
x_range = np.array([0, int(max_blobs)])
y_pred = intercept + slope * x_range
y_upper = y_pred + 2 * residual_std
y_lower = y_pred - 2 * residual_std

fig = go.Figure()

# Add ±2σ band
fig.add_trace(go.Scatter(
    x=np.concatenate([x_range, x_range[::-1]]),
    y=np.concatenate([y_upper, y_lower[::-1]]),
    fill="toself",
    fillcolor="rgba(100,100,100,0.2)",
    line=dict(width=0),
    name="±2σ band",
    hoverinfo="skip",
))

# Add regression line
fig.add_trace(go.Scatter(
    x=x_range,
    y=y_pred,
    mode="lines",
    line=dict(color="white", width=2, dash="dash"),
    name="Expected",
))

# Normal points (sample to avoid overplotting)
df_normal = df_anomaly[~df_anomaly["is_anomaly"]]
if len(df_normal) > 2000:
    df_normal = df_normal.sample(2000, random_state=42)

fig.add_trace(go.Scatter(
    x=df_normal["blob_count"],
    y=df_normal["block_first_seen_ms"],
    mode="markers",
    marker=dict(size=4, color="rgba(100,150,200,0.4)"),
    name=f"Normal ({len(df_anomaly) - n_anomalies:,})",
    hoverinfo="skip",
))

# Anomaly points
fig.add_trace(go.Scatter(
    x=df_outliers["blob_count"],
    y=df_outliers["block_first_seen_ms"],
    mode="markers",
    marker=dict(
        size=7,
        color="#e74c3c",
        line=dict(width=1, color="white"),
    ),
    name=f"Anomalies ({n_anomalies:,})",
    customdata=np.column_stack([
        df_outliers["slot"],
        df_outliers["residual_ms"].round(0),
        df_outliers["relay"],
    ]),
    hovertemplate="<b>Slot %{customdata[0]}</b><br>Blobs: %{x}<br>Actual: %{y:.0f}ms<br>+%{customdata[1]}ms vs expected<br>Relay: %{customdata[2]}<extra></extra>",
))

fig.update_layout(
    margin=dict(l=60, r=30, t=30, b=60),
    xaxis=dict(title="Blob count", range=[-0.5, int(max_blobs) + 0.5]),
    yaxis=dict(title="Block first seen (ms from slot start)"),
    legend=dict(orientation="h", yanchor="bottom", y=1.02, xanchor="right", x=1),
    height=500,
)
fig.show(config={"responsive": True})

All propagation anomalies

Blocks that propagated much slower than expected given their blob count, sorted by residual (worst first).

Show code
# All anomalies table with selectable text and Lab links
if n_anomalies > 0:
    df_table = df_outliers.sort_values("residual_ms", ascending=False)[
        ["slot", "blob_count", "block_first_seen_ms", "expected_ms", "residual_ms", "proposer", "builder", "relay"]
    ].copy()
    df_table["block_first_seen_ms"] = df_table["block_first_seen_ms"].round(0).astype(int)
    df_table["expected_ms"] = df_table["expected_ms"].round(0).astype(int)
    df_table["residual_ms"] = df_table["residual_ms"].round(0).astype(int)
    
    # Build HTML table
    html = '''
    <style>
    .anomaly-table { border-collapse: collapse; width: 100%; font-family: monospace; font-size: 13px; }
    .anomaly-table th { background: #2c3e50; color: white; padding: 8px 12px; text-align: left; position: sticky; top: 0; }
    .anomaly-table td { padding: 6px 12px; border-bottom: 1px solid #eee; }
    .anomaly-table tr:hover { background: #f5f5f5; }
    .anomaly-table .num { text-align: right; }
    .anomaly-table .delta { background: #ffebee; color: #c62828; font-weight: bold; }
    .anomaly-table a { color: #1976d2; text-decoration: none; }
    .anomaly-table a:hover { text-decoration: underline; }
    .table-container { max-height: 600px; overflow-y: auto; }
    </style>
    <div class="table-container">
    <table class="anomaly-table">
    <thead>
    <tr><th>Slot</th><th class="num">Blobs</th><th class="num">Actual (ms)</th><th class="num">Expected (ms)</th><th class="num">Δ (ms)</th><th>Proposer</th><th>Builder</th><th>Relay</th></tr>
    </thead>
    <tbody>
    '''
    
    for _, row in df_table.iterrows():
        slot_link = f'<a href="https://lab.ethpandaops.io/ethereum/slots/{row["slot"]}" target="_blank">{row["slot"]}</a>'
        html += f'''<tr>
            <td>{slot_link}</td>
            <td class="num">{row["blob_count"]}</td>
            <td class="num">{row["block_first_seen_ms"]}</td>
            <td class="num">{row["expected_ms"]}</td>
            <td class="num delta">+{row["residual_ms"]}</td>
            <td>{row["proposer"]}</td>
            <td>{row["builder"]}</td>
            <td>{row["relay"]}</td>
        </tr>'''
    
    html += '</tbody></table></div>'
    display(HTML(html))
    print(f"\nTotal anomalies: {len(df_table):,}")
else:
    print("No anomalies detected.")
SlotBlobsActual (ms)Expected (ms)Δ (ms)ProposerBuilderRelay
13367840 0 5446 1748 +3698 upbit Local Local
13370080 0 4955 1748 +3207 Local Local
13372616 0 4945 1748 +3197 whale_0xba8f Local Local
13372704 0 4739 1748 +2991 Local Local
13369071 0 4600 1748 +2852 Local Local
13372320 0 4552 1748 +2804 upbit Local Local
13372750 0 4371 1748 +2623 solo_stakers Local Local
13369166 0 4126 1748 +2378 solo_stakers Local Local
13372419 0 3927 1748 +2179 ether.fi Local Local
13371057 12 4005 1982 +2023 ether.fi 0xb26f9666... EthGas
13367350 0 3681 1748 +1933 ether.fi 0x82c466b9... EthGas
13370378 3 3738 1806 +1932 lido Local Local
13368011 0 3677 1748 +1929 lido 0x8a850621... Ultra Sound
13371674 4 3724 1826 +1898 ether.fi 0x856b0004... Agnostic Gnosis
13372224 6 3730 1865 +1865 blockdaemon_lido 0x88857150... Ultra Sound
13371176 0 3575 1748 +1827 0xb67eaa5e... Titan Relay
13368806 1 3591 1767 +1824 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13372960 2 3584 1787 +1797 blockdaemon_lido 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13370613 0 3533 1748 +1785 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13369759 8 3674 1904 +1770 ether.fi 0x856b0004... Aestus
13370575 7 3650 1884 +1766 0x853b0078... Ultra Sound
13367207 8 3669 1904 +1765 ether.fi 0x850b00e0... Flashbots
13373896 0 3511 1748 +1763 ether.fi 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Regulated
13371203 0 3503 1748 +1755 blockdaemon 0x853b0078... Ultra Sound
13369556 4 3579 1826 +1753 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13372263 2 3527 1787 +1740 ether.fi 0xac23f8cc... BloXroute Max Profit
13372541 0 3480 1748 +1732 blockdaemon 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13373541 1 3496 1767 +1729 ether.fi 0x853b0078... BloXroute Max Profit
13372638 5 3573 1845 +1728 revolut 0xb67eaa5e... Titan Relay
13370032 3 3531 1806 +1725 ether.fi 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13369610 0 3469 1748 +1721 ether.fi 0x91a8729e... BloXroute Max Profit
13370071 5 3552 1845 +1707 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368457 5 3536 1845 +1691 0x855b00e6... BloXroute Max Profit
13373357 0 3433 1748 +1685 0x8a850621... Ultra Sound
13372772 10 3626 1943 +1683 blockdaemon 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13372631 9 3603 1924 +1679 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13371731 3 3481 1806 +1675 lido 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13369017 7 3554 1884 +1670 figment 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13367153 8 3560 1904 +1656 ether.fi 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Max Profit
13368649 4 3480 1826 +1654 ether.fi 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13370742 7 3528 1884 +1644 blockdaemon 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13366999 5 3484 1845 +1639 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13370103 0 3363 1748 +1615 blockdaemon_lido 0x88857150... Ultra Sound
13371515 5 3456 1845 +1611 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13373609 5 3452 1845 +1607 blockdaemon 0x8a850621... Ultra Sound
13372309 3 3407 1806 +1601 blockdaemon 0x8a850621... Ultra Sound
13371234 5 3440 1845 +1595 solo_stakers Local Local
13367120 6 3438 1865 +1573 blockdaemon_lido 0xb67eaa5e... Titan Relay
13371072 8 3475 1904 +1571 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13370442 1 3337 1767 +1570 blockdaemon_lido 0xb67eaa5e... Titan Relay
13370332 5 3409 1845 +1564 blockdaemon 0x8a850621... Ultra Sound
13372305 11 3515 1963 +1552 blockdaemon 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13372526 1 3319 1767 +1552 0x82c466b9... BloXroute Regulated
13371496 4 3371 1826 +1545 blockdaemon_lido 0x88510a78... BloXroute Regulated
13367103 2 3325 1787 +1538 blockdaemon 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13373681 7 3421 1884 +1537 blockdaemon_lido 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13369070 0 3283 1748 +1535 blockdaemon 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13371704 1 3301 1767 +1534 luno 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13372731 4 3356 1826 +1530 blockdaemon 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13371710 5 3375 1845 +1530 blockdaemon_lido 0xb67eaa5e... Titan Relay
13370775 2 3316 1787 +1529 blockdaemon_lido 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13368864 4 3355 1826 +1529 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13368328 2 3306 1787 +1519 revolut 0x853b0078... Ultra Sound
13369939 0 3265 1748 +1517 luno 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368261 1 3280 1767 +1513 luno 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13367268 3 3317 1806 +1511 blockdaemon_lido 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13373333 0 3258 1748 +1510 blockdaemon_lido 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13371884 0 3252 1748 +1504 blockdaemon_lido 0x926b7905... BloXroute Regulated
13367247 12 3485 1982 +1503 blockdaemon_lido 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13369296 14 3522 2021 +1501 revolut 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13369082 5 3346 1845 +1501 blockdaemon 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13367127 2 3287 1787 +1500 blockdaemon 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13371242 0 3246 1748 +1498 p2porg 0x99dbe3e8... Aestus
13367011 0 3245 1748 +1497 0x91a8729e... BloXroute Regulated
13368320 5 3341 1845 +1496 stakingfacilities_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13371502 3 3301 1806 +1495 blockdaemon_lido 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13370903 1 3261 1767 +1494 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13366921 1 3258 1767 +1491 gateway.fmas_lido 0x8db2a99d... BloXroute Max Profit
13372026 5 3333 1845 +1488 blockdaemon_lido 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13371497 9 3410 1924 +1486 whale_0xdd6c 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13371819 6 3351 1865 +1486 blockdaemon 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Regulated
13369825 1 3250 1767 +1483 blockdaemon_lido 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13367635 11 3445 1963 +1482 blockdaemon_lido 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13371358 3 3284 1806 +1478 blockdaemon 0xb7c5c39a... BloXroute Regulated
13373733 2 3263 1787 +1476 0x853b0078... Ultra Sound
13366977 4 3301 1826 +1475 0x856b0004... Aestus
13366833 5 3316 1845 +1471 luno 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13368916 5 3315 1845 +1470 blockdaemon_lido 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13370678 0 3216 1748 +1468 abyss_finance 0xba003e46... Flashbots
13367318 0 3215 1748 +1467 luno 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13373879 4 3292 1826 +1466 revolut 0x856b0004... Ultra Sound
13370547 4 3289 1826 +1463 blockdaemon_lido 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13372683 3 3267 1806 +1461 blockdaemon_lido 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13373837 8 3362 1904 +1458 blockdaemon 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13372321 6 3318 1865 +1453 bitcoinsuisse Local Local
13373152 0 3197 1748 +1449 0x852b0070... BloXroute Max Profit
13368827 8 3352 1904 +1448 blockdaemon_lido 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13367599 5 3292 1845 +1447 blockdaemon 0x853b0078... Ultra Sound
13370446 5 3291 1845 +1446 blockdaemon_lido 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Regulated
13369037 3 3251 1806 +1445 blockdaemon_lido 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Regulated
13373322 0 3189 1748 +1441 blockdaemon_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13370375 6 3295 1865 +1430 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13372977 4 3255 1826 +1429 p2porg 0x855b00e6... BloXroute Max Profit
13372245 2 3212 1787 +1425 0x82c466b9... BloXroute Regulated
13371774 0 3172 1748 +1424 lido 0x852b0070... Ultra Sound
13370740 9 3343 1924 +1419 blockdaemon 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13372228 9 3343 1924 +1419 0x853b0078... Ultra Sound
13370628 10 3362 1943 +1419 blockdaemon_lido 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Regulated
13368207 0 3166 1748 +1418 p2porg 0x91a8729e... Ultra Sound
13370241 8 3321 1904 +1417 blockdaemon 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13368026 0 3162 1748 +1414 lido 0x853b0078... BloXroute Max Profit
13372695 4 3240 1826 +1414 0x853b0078... Titan Relay
13372385 5 3258 1845 +1413 p2porg 0x856b0004... Ultra Sound
13368003 5 3256 1845 +1411 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13366900 0 3158 1748 +1410 0x853b0078... BloXroute Max Profit
13369429 7 3294 1884 +1410 liquid_collective 0x853b0078... Ultra Sound
13372098 8 3311 1904 +1407 blockdaemon_lido 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13371883 0 3152 1748 +1404 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Regulated
13369902 6 3267 1865 +1402 revolut 0x853b0078... Ultra Sound
13370371 3 3207 1806 +1401 p2porg 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13368495 5 3246 1845 +1401 p2porg 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13369788 5 3245 1845 +1400 p2porg 0x823e0146... BloXroute Max Profit
13371800 4 3222 1826 +1396 0x853b0078... BloXroute Max Profit
13372423 12 3376 1982 +1394 luno 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13367433 7 3276 1884 +1392 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13371758 4 3217 1826 +1391 gateway.fmas_lido 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13373672 6 3256 1865 +1391 0x88857150... Ultra Sound
13370587 14 3412 2021 +1391 revolut 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13371455 5 3235 1845 +1390 blockdaemon 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13370364 0 3137 1748 +1389 stakingfacilities_lido 0x856b0004... Ultra Sound
13373058 1 3153 1767 +1386 everstake 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13372210 7 3270 1884 +1386 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13369651 7 3269 1884 +1385 blockdaemon_lido 0xa230e2cf... BloXroute Regulated
13370488 9 3307 1924 +1383 gateway.fmas_lido 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13370006 0 3130 1748 +1382 0x823e0146... BloXroute Max Profit
13368914 3 3186 1806 +1380 0x856b0004... Aestus
13370761 5 3225 1845 +1380 blockdaemon 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13369497 1 3145 1767 +1378 stakingfacilities_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368812 6 3242 1865 +1377 blockdaemon 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13370766 1 3144 1767 +1377 p2porg 0x853b0078... Agnostic Gnosis
13370059 5 3221 1845 +1376 p2porg 0x853b0078... Titan Relay
13367952 5 3219 1845 +1374 p2porg 0x856b0004... Aestus
13367825 6 3237 1865 +1372 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13373603 5 3217 1845 +1372 p2porg 0x853b0078... BloXroute Max Profit
13373445 1 3137 1767 +1370 0x856b0004... Aestus
13371971 3 3176 1806 +1370 p2porg 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13366841 4 3193 1826 +1367 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13369183 3 3172 1806 +1366 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Regulated
13371301 15 3406 2041 +1365 figment 0x856b0004... Ultra Sound
13369621 3 3171 1806 +1365 0x88857150... Ultra Sound
13369504 5 3210 1845 +1365 blockscape_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13369643 9 3288 1924 +1364 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13372737 6 3229 1865 +1364 blockdaemon 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13373142 0 3111 1748 +1363 0x852b0070... Aestus
13371816 0 3110 1748 +1362 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Regulated
13367157 0 3110 1748 +1362 0x8a850621... Ultra Sound
13370151 3 3168 1806 +1362 p2porg 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13373052 0 3106 1748 +1358 0xb26f9666... Aestus
13372970 0 3105 1748 +1357 figment 0xb67eaa5e... Titan Relay
13368302 3 3162 1806 +1356 p2porg 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368258 2 3142 1787 +1355 0xb26f9666... Aestus
13373239 3 3161 1806 +1355 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368911 8 3256 1904 +1352 gateway.fmas_lido 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13373757 1 3118 1767 +1351 0x856b0004... Agnostic Gnosis
13369636 5 3195 1845 +1350 ether.fi 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13370925 6 3214 1865 +1349 p2porg 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13369842 0 3096 1748 +1348 0x82c466b9... Flashbots
13367732 8 3250 1904 +1346 p2porg 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13371650 6 3208 1865 +1343 everstake 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13367516 0 3088 1748 +1340 0xb26f9666... Ultra Sound
13367549 1 3106 1767 +1339 0x853b0078... BloXroute Max Profit
13367152 7 3223 1884 +1339 0x8db2a99d... BloXroute Max Profit
13369554 1 3105 1767 +1338 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13368219 9 3261 1924 +1337 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13366944 3 3143 1806 +1337 nethermind_lido 0x853b0078... Agnostic Gnosis
13370558 0 3084 1748 +1336 0x91a8729e... BloXroute Max Profit
13370718 6 3201 1865 +1336 0x823e0146... BloXroute Max Profit
13369467 7 3216 1884 +1332 p2porg 0xb7c5e609... BloXroute Max Profit
13368942 0 3076 1748 +1328 p2porg 0x805e28e6... Flashbots
13371623 0 3075 1748 +1327 0xac23f8cc... BloXroute Max Profit
13370136 4 3153 1826 +1327 0x82c466b9... Flashbots
13368612 0 3073 1748 +1325 p2porg 0x852b0070... Aestus
13369149 0 3073 1748 +1325 p2porg 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13372493 5 3168 1845 +1323 p2porg 0x856b0004... Agnostic Gnosis
13370280 11 3284 1963 +1321 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Regulated
13373100 1 3087 1767 +1320 gateway.fmas_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13371416 8 3222 1904 +1318 bitstamp 0x8db2a99d... Ultra Sound
13373031 0 3064 1748 +1316 gateway.fmas_lido 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13368899 0 3064 1748 +1316 gateway.fmas_lido 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13373650 8 3219 1904 +1315 p2porg 0x856b0004... Ultra Sound
13366964 1 3082 1767 +1315 mantle 0xb7c5e609... BloXroute Max Profit
13373397 1 3079 1767 +1312 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13372201 5 3157 1845 +1312 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Max Profit
13369568 6 3175 1865 +1310 nethermind_lido 0x856b0004... Ultra Sound
13372546 3 3115 1806 +1309 p2porg 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13368100 5 3149 1845 +1304 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13371402 0 3051 1748 +1303 0x8db2a99d... BloXroute Max Profit
13368630 11 3265 1963 +1302 ether.fi 0xb26f9666... EthGas
13373749 0 3050 1748 +1302 p2porg 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Max Profit
13372534 1 3069 1767 +1302 gateway.fmas_lido 0xb7c5e609... BloXroute Max Profit
13366809 3 3108 1806 +1302 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13370061 7 3185 1884 +1301 whale_0x23be 0x860d4173... Flashbots
13373293 0 3048 1748 +1300 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368027 1 3067 1767 +1300 gateway.fmas_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13371003 1 3067 1767 +1300 everstake 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Max Profit
13371036 0 3047 1748 +1299 gateway.fmas_lido 0x852b0070... Aestus
13371370 0 3047 1748 +1299 everstake 0x823e0146... BloXroute Max Profit
13370025 1 3066 1767 +1299 p2porg 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13368123 1 3062 1767 +1295 0x823e0146... BloXroute Max Profit
13372398 5 3139 1845 +1294 gateway.fmas_lido 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13371420 0 3040 1748 +1292 everstake 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13367734 0 3038 1748 +1290 gateway.fmas_lido 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Max Profit
13370278 0 3038 1748 +1290 p2porg 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13368309 6 3155 1865 +1290 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Max Profit
13371563 1 3057 1767 +1290 everstake 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368665 1 3057 1767 +1290 gateway.fmas_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13369571 3 3095 1806 +1289 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13372537 0 3036 1748 +1288 everstake 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13371298 8 3192 1904 +1288 stakingfacilities_lido 0x856b0004... Ultra Sound
13369702 0 3035 1748 +1287 gateway.fmas_lido 0x91a8729e... BloXroute Max Profit
13372130 15 3328 2041 +1287 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368654 1 3054 1767 +1287 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13368910 0 3034 1748 +1286 0x91a8729e... Ultra Sound
13373000 4 3112 1826 +1286 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Regulated
13373161 1 3053 1767 +1286 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13367963 1 3051 1767 +1284 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Regulated
13371863 3 3090 1806 +1284 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13371676 3 3088 1806 +1282 p2porg 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13367989 1 3047 1767 +1280 everstake 0x856b0004... Aestus
13370314 0 3027 1748 +1279 gateway.fmas_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13372602 4 3105 1826 +1279 everstake 0x853b0078... BloXroute Max Profit
13371877 3 3085 1806 +1279 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Regulated
13370923 5 3124 1845 +1279 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13370416 5 3123 1845 +1278 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13370597 0 3025 1748 +1277 gateway.fmas_lido 0x91a8729e... Ultra Sound
13368549 5 3122 1845 +1277 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Max Profit
13367086 2 3063 1787 +1276 0x856b0004... Aestus
13370574 0 3023 1748 +1275 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13368797 1 3042 1767 +1275 gateway.fmas_lido 0x860d4173... Flashbots
13372555 0 3022 1748 +1274 everstake 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13368154 3 3079 1806 +1273 everstake 0x853b0078... Agnostic Gnosis
13367562 0 3018 1748 +1270 everstake 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13373643 9 3192 1924 +1268 p2porg 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Regulated
13369454 0 3016 1748 +1268 0x855b00e6... Flashbots
13369045 1 3035 1767 +1268 0x8db2a99d... Flashbots
13373417 2 3054 1787 +1267 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Max Profit
13373419 10 3209 1943 +1266 0x8a850621... BloXroute Max Profit
13367550 11 3228 1963 +1265 stakingfacilities_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368668 1 3030 1767 +1263 everstake 0x856b0004... Agnostic Gnosis
13369784 1 3030 1767 +1263 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13368869 3 3068 1806 +1262 gateway.fmas_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368787 0 3009 1748 +1261 everstake 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13372437 3 3067 1806 +1261 everstake 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13373898 0 3008 1748 +1260 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Regulated
13370884 5 3105 1845 +1260 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368697 0 3006 1748 +1258 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13371415 0 3005 1748 +1257 0x91a8729e... BloXroute Max Profit
13373507 0 3004 1748 +1256 p2porg 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13370867 3 3062 1806 +1256 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13367233 5 3101 1845 +1256 gateway.fmas_lido 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Regulated
13370524 0 3003 1748 +1255 0x91a8729e... BloXroute Max Profit
13369815 6 3118 1865 +1253 p2porg 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13372236 3 3058 1806 +1252 everstake 0x856b0004... Ultra Sound
13373671 9 3175 1924 +1251 stakingfacilities_lido 0xb26f9666... Ultra Sound
13369924 6 3116 1865 +1251 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13373135 0 2998 1748 +1250 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13372723 0 2998 1748 +1250 everstake 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Max Profit
13373512 8 3151 1904 +1247 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Max Profit
13369769 0 2993 1748 +1245 0x91a8729e... BloXroute Max Profit
13368823 3 3051 1806 +1245 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13369910 9 3168 1924 +1244 everstake 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Max Profit
13368030 0 2992 1748 +1244 0xb26f9666... Titan Relay
13368184 3 3049 1806 +1243 0x850b00e0... Flashbots
13370603 5 3088 1845 +1243 everstake 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13371818 0 2990 1748 +1242 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13369331 1 3006 1767 +1239 everstake 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13368208 5 3084 1845 +1239 gateway.fmas_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13373045 5 3084 1845 +1239 0x88a53ec4... BloXroute Max Profit
13368561 2 3025 1787 +1238 0x8a850621... Ultra Sound
13373395 5 3080 1845 +1235 gateway.fmas_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13367391 0 2982 1748 +1234 0x850b00e0... BloXroute Max Profit
13373044 2 3021 1787 +1234 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13372598 0 2981 1748 +1233 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Max Profit
13373994 0 2980 1748 +1232 0x91a8729e... BloXroute Max Profit
13370456 5 3076 1845 +1231 0xb67eaa5e... BloXroute Max Profit
13367174 3 3034 1806 +1228 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13371120 0 2974 1748 +1226 0x91a8729e... BloXroute Max Profit
13368983 0 2974 1748 +1226 everstake 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
13370616 8 3130 1904 +1226 everstake 0xb7c5e609... BloXroute Max Profit
13373540 5 3071 1845 +1226 0x823e0146... Flashbots
13373075 0 2972 1748 +1224 0xb26f9666... BloXroute Regulated
13370536 0 2972 1748 +1224 0xb7c5e609... BloXroute Max Profit
13371769 5 3069 1845 +1224 0x853b0078... Agnostic Gnosis
13371612 14 3244 2021 +1223 p2porg 0xa230e2cf... BloXroute Max Profit
13368603 0 2969 1748 +1221 0x852b0070... Agnostic Gnosis
13373860 5 3066 1845 +1221 gateway.fmas_lido 0x8527d16c... Ultra Sound
Total anomalies: 296

Anomalies by relay

Which relays produce the most propagation anomalies?

Show code
if n_anomalies > 0:
    # Count anomalies by relay
    relay_counts = df_outliers["relay"].value_counts().reset_index()
    relay_counts.columns = ["relay", "anomaly_count"]
    
    # Get total blocks per relay for context
    df_anomaly["relay"] = df_anomaly["winning_relays"].apply(lambda x: x[0] if len(x) > 0 else "Local")
    total_by_relay = df_anomaly.groupby("relay").size().reset_index(name="total_blocks")
    
    relay_counts = relay_counts.merge(total_by_relay, on="relay")
    relay_counts["anomaly_rate"] = relay_counts["anomaly_count"] / relay_counts["total_blocks"] * 100
    relay_counts = relay_counts.sort_values("anomaly_rate", ascending=True)
    
    fig = go.Figure()
    
    fig.add_trace(go.Bar(
        y=relay_counts["relay"],
        x=relay_counts["anomaly_count"],
        orientation="h",
        marker_color="#e74c3c",
        text=relay_counts.apply(lambda r: f"{r['anomaly_count']}/{r['total_blocks']} ({r['anomaly_rate']:.1f}%)", axis=1),
        textposition="outside",
        hovertemplate="<b>%{y}</b><br>Anomalies: %{x}<br>Total blocks: %{customdata[0]:,}<br>Rate: %{customdata[1]:.1f}%<extra></extra>",
        customdata=np.column_stack([relay_counts["total_blocks"], relay_counts["anomaly_rate"]]),
    ))
    
    fig.update_layout(
        margin=dict(l=150, r=80, t=30, b=60),
        xaxis=dict(title="Number of anomalies"),
        yaxis=dict(title=""),
        height=350,
    )
    fig.show(config={"responsive": True})

Anomalies by proposer entity

Which proposer entities produce the most propagation anomalies?

Show code
if n_anomalies > 0:
    # Count anomalies by proposer entity
    proposer_counts = df_outliers["proposer"].value_counts().reset_index()
    proposer_counts.columns = ["proposer", "anomaly_count"]
    
    # Get total blocks per proposer for context
    df_anomaly["proposer"] = df_anomaly["proposer_entity"].fillna("Unknown")
    total_by_proposer = df_anomaly.groupby("proposer").size().reset_index(name="total_blocks")
    
    proposer_counts = proposer_counts.merge(total_by_proposer, on="proposer")
    proposer_counts["anomaly_rate"] = proposer_counts["anomaly_count"] / proposer_counts["total_blocks"] * 100
    
    # Show top 15 by anomaly count
    proposer_counts = proposer_counts.nlargest(15, "anomaly_rate").sort_values("anomaly_rate", ascending=True)
    
    fig = go.Figure()
    
    fig.add_trace(go.Bar(
        y=proposer_counts["proposer"],
        x=proposer_counts["anomaly_count"],
        orientation="h",
        marker_color="#e74c3c",
        text=proposer_counts.apply(lambda r: f"{r['anomaly_count']}/{r['total_blocks']} ({r['anomaly_rate']:.1f}%)", axis=1),
        textposition="outside",
        hovertemplate="<b>%{y}</b><br>Anomalies: %{x}<br>Total blocks: %{customdata[0]:,}<br>Rate: %{customdata[1]:.1f}%<extra></extra>",
        customdata=np.column_stack([proposer_counts["total_blocks"], proposer_counts["anomaly_rate"]]),
    ))
    
    fig.update_layout(
        margin=dict(l=150, r=80, t=30, b=60),
        xaxis=dict(title="Number of anomalies"),
        yaxis=dict(title=""),
        height=450,
    )
    fig.show(config={"responsive": True})

Anomalies by builder

Which builders produce the most propagation anomalies? (Truncated pubkeys shown for MEV blocks)

Show code
if n_anomalies > 0:
    # Count anomalies by builder
    builder_counts = df_outliers["builder"].value_counts().reset_index()
    builder_counts.columns = ["builder", "anomaly_count"]
    
    # Get total blocks per builder for context
    df_anomaly["builder"] = df_anomaly["winning_builder"].apply(
        lambda x: f"{x[:10]}..." if pd.notna(x) and x else "Local"
    )
    total_by_builder = df_anomaly.groupby("builder").size().reset_index(name="total_blocks")
    
    builder_counts = builder_counts.merge(total_by_builder, on="builder")
    builder_counts["anomaly_rate"] = builder_counts["anomaly_count"] / builder_counts["total_blocks"] * 100
    
    # Show top 15 by anomaly count
    builder_counts = builder_counts.nlargest(15, "anomaly_rate").sort_values("anomaly_rate", ascending=True)
    
    fig = go.Figure()
    
    fig.add_trace(go.Bar(
        y=builder_counts["builder"],
        x=builder_counts["anomaly_count"],
        orientation="h",
        marker_color="#e74c3c",
        text=builder_counts.apply(lambda r: f"{r['anomaly_count']}/{r['total_blocks']} ({r['anomaly_rate']:.1f}%)", axis=1),
        textposition="outside",
        hovertemplate="<b>%{y}</b><br>Anomalies: %{x}<br>Total blocks: %{customdata[0]:,}<br>Rate: %{customdata[1]:.1f}%<extra></extra>",
        customdata=np.column_stack([builder_counts["total_blocks"], builder_counts["anomaly_rate"]]),
    ))
    
    fig.update_layout(
        margin=dict(l=150, r=80, t=30, b=60),
        xaxis=dict(title="Number of anomalies"),
        yaxis=dict(title=""),
        height=450,
    )
    fig.show(config={"responsive": True})

Anomalies by blob count

Are anomalies more common at certain blob counts?

Show code
if n_anomalies > 0:
    # Count anomalies by blob count
    blob_anomalies = df_outliers.groupby("blob_count").size().reset_index(name="anomaly_count")
    blob_total = df_anomaly.groupby("blob_count").size().reset_index(name="total_blocks")
    
    blob_stats = blob_total.merge(blob_anomalies, on="blob_count", how="left").fillna(0)
    blob_stats["anomaly_count"] = blob_stats["anomaly_count"].astype(int)
    blob_stats["anomaly_rate"] = blob_stats["anomaly_count"] / blob_stats["total_blocks"] * 100
    
    fig = go.Figure()
    
    fig.add_trace(go.Bar(
        x=blob_stats["blob_count"],
        y=blob_stats["anomaly_count"],
        marker_color="#e74c3c",
        hovertemplate="<b>%{x} blobs</b><br>Anomalies: %{y}<br>Total: %{customdata[0]:,}<br>Rate: %{customdata[1]:.1f}%<extra></extra>",
        customdata=np.column_stack([blob_stats["total_blocks"], blob_stats["anomaly_rate"]]),
    ))
    
    fig.update_layout(
        margin=dict(l=60, r=30, t=30, b=60),
        xaxis=dict(title="Blob count", dtick=1),
        yaxis=dict(title="Number of anomalies"),
        height=350,
    )
    fig.show(config={"responsive": True})